Monday, December 15, 2008
History and Memory
I know, I know, its been done to death. I was just thinking about oral tradition stories, and whether to classify them as history or memory. A lot of the old testament is based in oral tradition, and it certainly presents itself as a history of the world in the time before the invention of written documentation, even if we heathens don't believe in the events. I think I would say oral tradition is supposed to be either history or a regular old piece of fiction, but because it is passed from generation to generation, it can't really be a memory. I was also thinking about the reason memory can change over time, and I think it comes down to emotion. Because the way you feel about something can change over time, the memories of those things are equally distorted. Like when Amaranta began to hate Rebeca, the memories of her, even the happy ones, would surely be distorted and baddenered, especially as time passed. But if you have a story or a history already written down, its harder to retain the same kind of subjectivity. I don't want to talk about it anymore, I'm sick of it.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
I'm going to leave you a comment here even though you're sick of it...
I might say that oral tradition is at once history and fiction. In a time in which history, news and current events were conveyed orally, I am sure that they were highly fictionalized (even more so than they are now). The story that is told, then, while not an individual memory may well work its way into a collective memory, into the identity of a community
This is different than what you were getting at i think but it interested me anyway. You talked about the bible and oral traditions. This book kind of is a lot like the bible in a way(good sentence?). This is because if we look at the old testament we see things that seem to be magic. Like the story of moses and the plagues, the guy that i can't spell his name who was like over a thousand years old, sampson was a guy whose entire power came from his hair. All of this things are accepted and by really religious people are believe to have happened. when asked why that doesn't happen now the answer would be "those were the olden times, anything was possible" As macondo moves into the future...or present... or whatever, it is losing more and more magic and becoming more and more like a town of today.
I just see a lot of similarities
Post a Comment